Harold's older brother Fayard (1914-2006)
Here's the two of them together, but the above photo is a bit misleading, as the Nicholas Brothers were rarely seen...
I briefly wondered if I should do this post as an "Under the Radar", my recurring feature dedicated to talented people who never quite achieved fame, but the above advertisement convinced me that the Nicholas Brothers were famous enough, at least in their day. Touring the continent--that would be Europe--triumphant appearances in England, France, Sweden, Portugal, Italy and Denmark. Unfortunately, here in North America, the continent of their birth, there were no triumphant appearances in the United States South, either live or on film. On the latter score, their motion pictures either were all-black productions (and often shorts) which never made it past the Mason-Dixon line, or mostly white pictures that featured the two of them in specialty numbers (one of which they shared with a pre-Carmen Jones Dorothy Dandridge, Harold's then-wife) that existed outside a movie's main storyline, so as to be easily edited out when it was shown in the land of Dixie. But such scenes weren't edited from the films shown in London, where Harold and Fayard became popular enough to warrant a Royal Command Performance in 1948. What did King George VI care about Jim Crow?
Produced by Jack Haley Jr (the Tin Man's boy), 1985's That's Dancing! was an offshoot of Haley's That's Entertainment! film compilations. Starting in 1974, these were themselves theatrical films that celebrated the heyday of the Hollywood musical. What made TD! a bit different from TE!, is the latter was solely dedicated to Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, which could give someone too young to enjoy that heyday the misleading impression that only MGM made musicals in the 1930s, '40s, and '50s. In fact, all the major Hollywood studios produced musicals. It was a very popular form of movie entertainment in that era. Now at the time Metro did have deeper pockets than the other studios, and eventually was able to lure stars of the genre who had originally achieved success elsewhere. For instance, Fred Astaire first rose to fame at RKO before hearing the roar of Leo the Lion. Astaire eventually danced through enough of MGM's Metrocolor product to be featured quite prominently in all three That's Entertainment! movies, but was never seen dancing with Ginger Rogers in black-and-white. That's Dancing! redresses this imbalance by showing production numbers from all the major studios, thus giving you a more rounded picture of motion picture history (part of MGM's generosity in that regard may have had something to do with then-owner Ted Turner also owning the film libraries of several of its competitors, but I'm just speculating.) The Nicholas Brothers did do one film for Metro, The Pirate, but most of their cinematic movements were at 20th Century Fox (which I guess qualifies them these days as Disney Legends), including Down Argentina Way, which is featured in That's Dancing! Because it's a bit similar to another clip I want to show you, I'm going to skip DAW for now, but I will show you Harold and Fayard, now in their golden years, promoting the release of That's Dancing! Watch:
They seem like a couple of nice guys.
And they were a couple of nice kids. Their mother was a pianist and father a drummer who played in their own band at Philadelphia's Standard Theatre, which from 1914 to 1931 specialized in black vaudeville entertainment. Oldest boy Fayard got to see all the top black entertainers at his parents' place of employment and obviously was quite taken with the dancers. Entirely self-trained, he taught his sister Dorothy and kid brother Harold how to dance, and they formed their own act, The Nicholas Kids. Dorothy soon dropped out and that was when the act's name was changed to The Nicholas Brothers (of course they were that before there ever was an act.) Their combination of tap and acrobatics got them noticed pretty quickly, playing not just the Standard but now-legendary Cotton Club (though at the latter only white audiences were allowed to see them perform, discrimination at its most head-scratching.) Then came Broadway. The Ziegfeld Follies of 1936 (a show that also featured Bob Hope and Josephine Baker), and the very next year Rodgers and Hart's Babes in Arms. All well and good, but none of that meant posterity. For that you needed moving pictures, especially for those two, who, after all, moved pretty damn fast, examples of which now follow.
First up is a scene from an all-black movie about an all-black radio station none-too-subtly titled The Black Network. Fayard is 21 (but looks 15) and Harold is 15 (but looks 10.) Watch:
As you watched them dance, did you keep in mind that it's supposed to be a radio audition? At least it was tap and not ballet.
Finally, we jump ahead seven years to 1943, by which time both brothers were old enough to drink, not that it matters since they couldn't possibly have done what you're about to see next unless they were cold sober. Deciding to do it in the first place, then they might have been as high as a Sun Valley chairlift. Here's the preternaturally amazing Nicholas Brothers at their amplified-tapping, gravity-defying, land speed record-breaking, bone fracture-resistant best. But first you have to sit through a few minutes of Cab Calloway (and that, my friends, is hardly a hellish experience):
And to think, spandex hadn't even been invented yet!
They had long, impressive careers, so much talent, and were incredible athletes, too. I never tire of watching them perform.
ReplyDeleteMitchell, it's all I can do to scroll down this page without first stopping and watching them dance one more time.
DeleteHandsome men, as pre Carmen Miranda person thought of Harold. They are great performers, especially dancing. I wonder what they would have looked like in spandex 😉
ReplyDeleteAndrew, they would have looked like they belonged in the Summer Olympics.
DeleteAnd maybe gotten their own calendar.
DeleteThat's nothing. Shady practically invented the funky robot!
ReplyDeleteHi, Kirk!
Happy 101st birthday in heaven to Harold Nicholas. I read that Harold, the younger brother, died of heart failure a few years earlier than the older brother (as you noted). Fayard, who lived to be 91, attended Harold's funeral.
I'm amazed, good buddy. I couldn't believe my eyes as I watched The Nicholas Brothers' acrobatic dance routine in that last video. How they were able to do those splits leaping down the stairs is beyond me. My weak joints would never tolerate such a thing. Imagine, as they were jumping from one elevated surface to the next, if there had been only a slight miscalculation on the part of one brother, it could have resulted in a fall and devastating injury that would have brought their act to an abrupt end. They were brilliant dancers, great singers and showmen, clearly intelligent and articulate, and seemed like genuinely nice guys. It is funny that they tap danced on a radio show, requiring the listener to use his imagination. When I was very young, I went with my parents to a Cab Calloway show, probably at the York Fair. Although I don't watch many musicals, I must have seen The Nicholas Brothers perform in feature films or documentaries over the years. It was great to see them again and learn about them.
Thank you for paying tribute to these gifted brothers, good buddy Kirk. I thoroughly enjoyed the show!
Great retrospective! Wonderful to learn more about them. So tragic that their times stunted their career success which they should otherwise have had.
ReplyDeleteThe fate of many a black artist from that era, Debra.
DeleteShady, I just watched the Jumping Jive number again--I couldn't resist--and while the leg splits are what understandably gets the most attention, that the Nicholas Brothers danced up the knee-high steps in the first place is pretty amazing. CLIMBING up would have been a workout enough for me. And after those leg splits, as well toward the end when both are on their knees, Fayard's and Harold's ability to rise up from the floor without actually touching the floor with their hands seems to me to violate some law of physics. In the interview, Fayard admits it wasn't done in a single take, but if it's edited, when was the camera turned off and turned back on again? It looks to me like one long tracking shot, the musical Orson Welles never made.
ReplyDeleteI'd like to add another zinger if it's not too late:
DeleteThat's nothing. I once saw Lionel Richie dancing on the ceiling!
So did Fred Astaire
DeleteI'm sure my father has heard of them as he loves all those old movies, with dancing/singing. I have not. But I love learning about these historical tidbits!
ReplyDeleteI'm happy to teach you, JM.
DeleteHello Kirk, Thanks for introducing me to these two amazing artists. I looked at their Wikipedia article, and it states that the steps routine was done in one take and without rehearsal, which is nothing less than phenomenal. As to cutting out their numbers from films, I sure you are absolutely correct, but consider also that in musicals of that time, the numbers were disconnected from the plot, and sometimes performed in a "variety" format, so the routines were easily excised from the film for reasons of timing, continuity, licensing, etc. If Southern audiences elected to have these performers deleted for racist reasons, then they certainly did not deserve to witness such virtuosity.
ReplyDelete--Jim
Well, yes, Jim, things get excised from movies for all kinds of reasons. And blacks weren't always cut from movies shown to white audiences in the South. Gone with the Wind had its premiere in Atlanta with all the Hattie McDaniel and Butterfly McQueen scenes intact. But those actresses played slaves! Stephen Fetchit probably never got cut from a movie shown in the Jim Crow South either, at least not for reasons having to do with race. It's when the glamour of the black stars threatened to match that of white stars that the scissors came out. Lena Horne, for instance, also was regularly cut from movies shown in the South.
DeleteOf course, there were a lot of black people living in the South during the Jim Crow era, and at least some of them could afford to go to movies--as long as the movies were shown in segregated theatres. So, they, at least, were southerners who got to witness the virtuosity of the Nicholas Brothers.
Aw, the Nicholas brothers. What a great contribution to the entertainment industry. Such legends and deserving of honor. Thanks for sharing this. I must admit, there are many music icons I'm yet to know about.
ReplyDeleteLux, every generation gets their own show biz icons, and I would never criticize somebody for being unaware of a star whose heyday was from before they were born. But if someone young discovers and get turned on to a name from yesteryear simply by checking my little blog out, well, that's fantastic.
Delete